Have Faith, Panthers Fans - Gettleman and Rivera on Top of their Game
/
It's a bit of a stormy Saturday
afternoon outside and one I don't want to dabble in and got to thinking.
Yes - in my
case, a mind is a terrible thing, but putting that aside for the moment, please
humor me with a few minutes of your time to help calm your fears over recent
events regarding the Carolina Panthers.
I just
wanted to share my impressions of some of the things I've been seeing and
hearing over the past couple of months regarding the roster and wanted to try
and help keep the "fanship" on a bit more even-keel by pointing out a
few things that we DO know and see where that leads us, hm?
Okay.
Please
forgive any "rambling" here, but I'm trying to tie together a number
of angles and it must necessarily be a bit wordy. Lots of information looked
at, I promise. Bear with me. I gave up half a Saturday for you, so cut me some
slack on this one okay? ;)
Despite any
PC-like quotes Rivera may or may not say about a specific player, like DeSean
"We'd be interested in looking at him" Jackson, General Manager David
Gettleman has made things very, very clear on numerous occasions. In short, he
wants to be able to have the ability to keep our home-grown "Star"
(pun intended SO much) talent in Charlotte, and past the rookie four to
five-year deals they start their careers there under.
Boiling it
down, the two gentlemen - Gettleman and Rivera - are specific and ownership has
its' say too:
"You
don't want to be in a situation where you're four or five years into a guy and
look around and say 'Hey, we can't afford to keep this guy!"
I think
that's a Gettleman quote but Rivera wouldn't deny saying it either. That's the
one thing they appear unified upon is holding on to their stars....yes,
"Star" Lotulelei included with fellow tackle Kawann Short along with
Luke and Cam.
It would
also fit into the puzzle as to why they franchised Greg Hardy. They aren't 100%
sold on him, only 95%, and what if he got hurt in 2014, and what if he got hit
in the rear-end with a meteorite?
They pushed
the decision on him down the road for a year because it was pushable.
They don't
mind paying him what he's scheduled - $11.8 million-ish - for the season. If a
freak injury happens, that's horrible but it's business and the organization
isn't on the hook for 'em yet, either. When the cap increases next year, more
players rotate into the picture as well but it leaves them with more options.
Marty Hurney
would have signed Hardy to the Huge Megadeal this year. Gettleman, being
shrewder and plausibly appealing to The Kraken's sense of loyalty and
understanding about Hurney and the cap issues, retains Hardy's services for
2014 either way. The way they did it is just so that the organization, for
reasons that are unlikely to happen, aren't on the hook for him over the
long-term this year.
Meanwhile,
the team retains as much control over a player as there is in a given season and the Franchise Tag acts as a no-cost short-term insurance policy, if nothing
else.
Players
sometimes huff at "The Label" being put on them and to his credit,
Hardy hasn't said a bad word about it to my knowledge. We all know he'd have
preferred a long-term deal this season. The Kraken is obviously an intelligent
and astute self-promoter who uses the team as a platform to increase value in
"his brand" AKA The Kraken.
I digress a
tad on Hardy to make a point.
When you
look with a more of a "Forest for the Trees" approach, it makes
logical sense and it also means the team is looking to improve via the NFL
draft, PERIOD!
That's the
key to long-term success in the NFL. Seattle and Green Bay are two
organizations that come to mind as being high in the "home-grown"
department in general. Patriots too. So long as the Pack has AR-12, they'll probably
contend. Seattle has been a team on the rise over the past few years and won
the Super Bowl by completely destroying the NFL's most prolific offense ever.
That points
to two things - defense wins championships as we all know but homegrown teams breed
long-term sustainability. The Niners are another team that fits this bill. It's
scary to think what they'll do with Frank Gore and a healthy Marcus Lattimore,
isn't it? Nobody's talking about that right now. He was a fourth-rounder a year
ago that they knew wouldn't see the field that year but were looking over a
multi-seasonal period of time. At his physical peak, before a nasty lower-leg
injury, he would be head and shoulders the top RB in this year's class. The
Niners got him a year ago for a 4th rather than say a 2nd this season...and
possibly 30th overall, even. Lattimore was that renowned at South Carolina and,
before his Theismann-esque leg injury, had become nationally noticed.
It's the
smart moves like that - assuming he works as advertised - that can make a team
over the long run. If Lattimore is Gore's successor, he can prove it on the
field.
While the
Panthers have hit their share of gems, they've been at the predictable (now)
places - Cam and Luke. Star and K-Short will join 'em up there if they keep
playing the way they did as rookies and get better with experience, but Star
especially looks like a keeper inside.
That's QB,
MLB and DE nailed shut for 2014. Out of sight, out of mind for now. Star and Kawann have several more years before their contracts renew.
Focusing on
the apparent lack of talent at the other positions carries an obvious risk on
both sides but we have to see the two Head Cheeses' outward calm. We also have to
realize they're executing a much, much longer-range plan than we fans are
yelling about. Smitty one day, Ginn and LaFell gone. No D-Jax in sight and
Jordan Gross retired.
All of this
while not giving any thought to several phases of talent acquisition still open
for us: free agency, "The Draft," and unrestricted free agency. More
on the last part in a moment.
They can't
shell out $2 million or $1.5 million here or there for a Ginn, Munnerlyn, or
what others signed for with other teams and expect for the money to be there
when it's needed the most.
Rivera
likened the salary cap jump of $10 million this year to having a credit card
and getting a bonus. The smart thing is to pay down on what you owe so room is
there when you need it. That's when the names came up. I don't recall Hardy's
by name - so file that one away for next year perhaps - but wasn't looking for
it particularly at the time, either. Gotta check on that.
Remember
that so-called "role-players" are named that for a distinct reason
that is self-apparent. They're the expendable ones - the pawns, if you will.
The number of those you can plan on having by the end of the following season
is near zero when they are signed, so don't let that scare you too much.
We also have
to look at in-house talent for solutions first. Could the team have signed a
free agent that could help win us ball games for years to come? If the answer
is no, the point is moot. If yes (D-Jax fans), is it worth his price?
We aren't
sure of his price, but it's likely to be in the double-digit range annually.
Here's what
you don't want to hear - Smitty became expendable this year and his strong
personality is probably the line of demarcation. He's just too intense to keep
paying with declining skills while a kid 12 years younger can do the same things without the mouth, and that's before Jackson became available to not consider.
That's the
reality of it and its got the Brain Trust's (Gettleman/Rivera/Ownership)
fingerprints all over it - akin to a somewhat messy celebrity divorce that the
Brain Trust poorly executed.
It's the
biggest mistake of the Gettleman Era....not in letting him loose but in how
they mishandled it in a PR way.
The NFL
draft is in May, and a bigger, stronger, faster, more "21st-Century"
receiver will likely be available then or perhaps Brandin Cooks is Jackson's rookie
clone. Perhaps there's a budding star they're high on in-house and we just
don't know it yet? Too many variables right now to righteously panic.
I do like
Underwood for the price, and for the record. Clowney may start faster but is a
31 yr old veteran who was acquired as much for his locker room stability and to "mentor" the team's younger receivers as for his on-field ability...and his low price tag.
It appears
the last "second-tier" LT prospect can pretty solidly be had by
Carolina's fourth-round pick or the third for certain, The Brain Trust wants to use
picks 28 and 60 overall on the BPA (Best Player Available) that comes anywhere
close to being a position of any need. Doing the same in the third would be
great, but you don't always get the breaks. Gettleman comes from the New York
Giants who already had a reputation for drafting great linebackers in the '80's
and '90's even though they had depth as he was earning his NFL stripes as a scout. That had to have had an effect on his own approach to the draft.
So what we
have is a group of men who appear to be taking that very long term
organizational approach and not jumping on a flashy, undersized WR with an even
larger price tag. Ain't gonna happen and never was looking back. Should've been
obvious at the time and I never wanted him. Why not?
See above.
We could get a rookie in the draft with those skills - yes, in a draft
supposedly with the deepest talent pool in over a decade - anywhere probably up
through the third, perhaps the fourth round.
Assuming we
have no talent in-house lurking around about to burst out (save for RG Edmund
Kugbila perhaps) into NFL games, we still need WR, CB, LT the most. Signing
Roman Harper kicked that safety can down the road unless one "falls"
to them.
What will
you say when those positions are among the top-four or five in the Panthers'
draft? It's less than six weeks away. After that, there's the UFAs (Undrafted
Free Agents) to sign. Ever hear of a guy named Victor Cruz? Gettleman's doing -
in the UFA stage - his final season in New York.
There you
go.
The
philosophy is to let the talent come to you; do not reach or over-reach for it. Fall in love with your true stars - Cam, Luke, Star, The Kraken, possibly Short and Thomas Davis. Those are the guys you want to keep above all else - the rest are expendable and you build around your core talent.
Therefore, for example, I don't think the team would "reach" for a Morgan Moses in the first when others that probably are nearly equal prospects could be taken as late as the fourth or fifth rounds. Look at smaller schools like Nevada and South Dakota State U for those guys.
Therefore, for example, I don't think the team would "reach" for a Morgan Moses in the first when others that probably are nearly equal prospects could be taken as late as the fourth or fifth rounds. Look at smaller schools like Nevada and South Dakota State U for those guys.
If any
"reaching" is done...isn't it better to do so using a later pick than
an earlier one? Last year, DT Star Lotulelei was talked about as the top or a
sure-fire top-three pick in the draft until a heart issue sidelined him at the
NFL Combine.
It was temporary - I personally spoke with two of the team doctors about this specific issue myself - and Star had a very good prognosis by draft day. He still fell and the Panthers had the luxury of drafting their BPA that happened to also fit the team's biggest need.
It was temporary - I personally spoke with two of the team doctors about this specific issue myself - and Star had a very good prognosis by draft day. He still fell and the Panthers had the luxury of drafting their BPA that happened to also fit the team's biggest need.
It also
explains the Kuechly pick the previous year above any said need at defensive
tackle. Beason was healthy, but by choosing Kuechly, we have the NFL's best inside linebacker and in
grabbing Star before he fell any further, bang-bang we have two
"core" players with consecutive top picks.
Toss in Cam the previous season and it's three-for-three.
Toss in Cam the previous season and it's three-for-three.
Liking that
track record, I see the Panthers going about it that way. After their draft,
you'll probably scratch your head (as I probably will) when they hit up a
center in the 5th or something. That's one effect of things - picks that don't
seem to make sense position-wise. Kenyon Barner last year? BPA. Kugbila too.
Unfortunately,
what all these things have in common is that the Panthers' Brass knows their
core players really are only a handful of guys and the others are all
expendable.
Beason.
James Anderson. Captain. Smitty (!?!) Ginn. LaFell. The one I miss the
most is Mike Mitchell and he's the one guy I think Rivera wishes he could have
kept. In his place is Roman Harper, whom they did sign in free agency - along
with WRs Cotchery and Underwood.
What - you
want DeSean Jackson talent for only a few million a year?
That's what
the NFL Draft is for!!!