Whatever it is, at least some of Dave Gettleman's favorite things to look for have revealed themselves to me. First of all, he likes smart guys. You can see that in his middle-round selections when he took, for instance, David Mayo. Gettleman also likes guys who are productive, as in Mayo's case, and most certainly in Kuechly's case. With Kuechly, he had brains, productions AND eye-popping Combine numbers and likely was #1 on our draft board overall. Middle linebackers slide a bit in drafts because of the below average "positional value," but that's another discussion entirely.
Two-Time Super Bowl-winning coach of the Dallas Cowboys, Jimmy Johnson, has a saying: "Someone, PLEASE hit me in the HEAD with a HAMMER if I ever even THINK about drafting a DUMB guy again!"
That says quite a lot, considering the source.
Lastly, look at many of the players in the NFL's Hall of Fame. Every last one of them that I have seen or heard speak has been better than average in expressing themselves and seems to be quite intelligent when speaking about a given subject or answering interview questions. Sure, some of them might have a bit flashier personalities than you might like to see, but I have yet to hear of anyone question, for example, Richard Sherman's intelligence. Bright guy - just has a big mouth. But he always backs it up, like him or not.
A Good Wonderlic Score Doesn't Guarantee Success
This came to me a bit over time more than having something "click" in my mind to realize it, but the time that passes only reinforces the idea. The Wonderlic may not be a very big factor in and of itself during the player evaluation process, but I think it still helps provide clues as to what a particular player's mental make-up is and should produce a line of questions that need to get answered.
Perhaps someone could just be good at doing basic math in his head. That would give him a leg up on the test right there. Perhaps some know "test taking skills" - for example, skipping longer questions and answering the easiest ones first, since it's 50 questions in eight minutes, it's not designed to be finished.
There's another place where intelligence shows up - the brighter guys are going to realize this and adjust....just like you have to do in the NFL. In fact if I were taking it, I'd make sure I do NOT score above about a 36 or 38. I'd want to fall in that "high sweet-spot" that isn't SO high it raises questions about my coachability and not low at all to raise questions about my innate intelligence. That's how *I* would "adjust," anyway.
As you can see by that 2013 QB chart, a high or a good score on Wonderlic doesn't guarantee a thing. Gabbert was tops on that list, but at the bottom of the barrel of NFL QBs. Cam is near the bottom and just signed a contract worth $60 million guaranteed. Aaron Rodgers made a 35; So did Christian Ponder.